The Best Non Toxic Waterproof Mascara

This post: The BEST non toxic waterproof mascara that’s in my makeup bag these days—and it *doesn’t budge* in heat, sweat, or tears.

I don’t play games when it comes to waterproof mascara.

I want to be able to swim, cry, or go on a humid Texas walk without ending up with raccoon eyes.
Smudge, smear, flake? Nope. Not on my face.

Tall order? Maybe.

But I’ve found the one.

Forever Lash: The BEST Non-Toxic Waterproof Mascara

by Billion Dollar Beauty

This is the only mascara I use now—and it’s officially earned a permanent spot in my summer makeup routine.

Why I Love It:

• Clean beauty product
• Affordable ($19)
• Smooth, no-clump application
• Totally smudge-proof
• Texas-tested: heat + humidity resistant
• 100% waterproof
• Easy to remove (I use coconut oil)

I haven’t found this brand in any Fort Worth beauty stores, so I always order online and restock before summer kicks into high gear.

Is it actually swim-proof and cry-proof?

Let’s just say:

• We went to an indoor water park.
• I wore this mascara.
• My lashes looked flawless after 6 hours of chlorine, slides, and 100°+ Texas humidity.

Then I cried happy tears last week—full-on sobbing—and still no smudge.

I’m hard on my makeup… and this holds up.

🛍️ Want to build a waterproof eye bundle?

Check out the Waterproof Eye Kit from Billion Dollar Beauty—I’ve used all three and love them:

• Brows on Point Micro Brow Pencil
• Forever Lash Black Waterproof Mascara
• Liquid Eyeliner

The full set is just $37 (regularly $54), available in blonde, taupe, and raven.

Prefer to browse & shop my beauty routine?

Find this mascara (plus the rest of my minimalist favorites) in my ShopMy Store. (You’ll also see what I use for full hot weather makeup that won’t melt off in the heat.)

💬 FAQs: Best non toxic waterproof mascara

Q: What’s the best non-toxic waterproof mascara for hot weather?
I swear by Forever Lash by Billion Dollar Beauty. It’s smudge-proof, sweat-proof, and doesn’t budge—even in humid Texas summers.

Q: Is this mascara clean and cruelty-free?
Yes! It’s vegan, cruelty-free, paraben-free, and BeVeg certified.

Q: Can I really wear this mascara swimming?
Absolutely. I’ve worn it to a water park and through literal tears—it does not move.

Q: Where can I buy this mascara?
I order it online. It’s not yet available locally here in Fort Worth.

Q: Does it come off easily?
Surprisingly, yes! I just use coconut oil or a gentle oil-based cleanser at night.

Shop My Favorites

✅ Forever Lash Mascara
✅ Waterproof Eye Kit
✅ Full summer routine on ShopMy

Affiliate Disclaimer:

I’m an affiliate for ShopMy, which means I may earn a small commission if you shop through my links—at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting my site! xo

Want your own ShopMy page? It’s free and easy to set up.